Mother wrongly jailed for 20 years over death of her 4 children has convictions quashed

News Express |14th Dec 2023 | 404
Mother wrongly jailed for 20 years over death of her 4 children has convictions quashed




An Australian mother who spent two decades in prison after she was wrongly found guilty of killing her four children had her convictions formally quashed Thursday, as her lawyers called for legal reform and substantial compensation.

Kathleen Folbigg was pardoned and freed in June on the recommendation of retired judge Tom Bathurst, who re-examined all the evidence put to her 2003 trial and found reasonable doubt as to her guilt.

But clearing her name required a formal ruling by the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal, and on Thursday, a panel of judges agreed she should be acquitted of all charges, concluding one of the countrys most prominent miscarriages of justice.

Outside the court, an emotional Folbigg thanked supporters who worked tirelessly to convince the NSW government and legal system that new scientific evidence warranted closer scrutiny of her convictions.

The time this has taken in seeing todays result has cost many people a lot, Folbigg said, as she stood beside her lawyers and closest friends. I hoped and prayed that one day I would be able to stand here with my name cleared.

Folbigg was jailed in 2003 on three counts of murder and one of manslaughter following the deaths of her four babies over a decade from 1989.

No physical proof was submitted that she had killed them, but the jury was convinced that the chances of all four dying from natural causes was so unlikely that it must have been murder. Certain passages in her diary were also interpreted as admissions of guilt.

As recently as 2019, an inquiry into her convictions found there was no reasonable doubt she had committed the crimes. But another inquiry began in 2022 after scientists discovered a previously unknown mutant gene in her two daughters that could have been fatal.

The evidence provided a genetic explanation for the childrens deaths, which created reasonable doubt about her convictions, and enough to convince a judge to recommend her pardon.

Wrongful convictions

Folbiggs first baby Caleb died in 1989, followed by Patrick in 1991, Sarah in 1993 and finally Laura in 1999.

The first three deaths were initially attributed to Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS), a term used when babies under 1 die for no apparent reason.

At 18 months, Laura was the longest lived of Folbiggs children, and police began investigating after a forensic pathologist marked the cause of her death as undetermined. She was charged and convicted as newspaper headlines declared her to be Australias worst serial killer.

For decades, Folbigg languished in prison despite acquittals in similar cases in the United Kingdom that had also relied on Meadows law, the false maxim pushed by discredited British pediatrician Roy Meadow that one sudden infant death in a family is a tragedy, two is suspicious and three is murder.

On Thursday, Chief Justice Andrew Bell said the appeals court judges agreed with Bathursts findings that substantial and extensive body of new scientific evidence outweighed evidence heard at her trial. They also found that her diaries, when viewed in the full context supported by new expert psychological and psychiatric evidence, were not reliable admissions of guilt.

Outside the court, Folbiggs lawyer Rhanee Rego said Folbiggs legal team will now seek compensation, which she predicted would be substantial.

Im not prepared to put a figure on it, but it will be bigger than any substantial payment that has been made before, she said.

More importantly, theyre pushing all Australian states to create an independent body for review, such as a Criminal Cases Review Commission, to prevent future miscarriages of justice.

An innocent woman suffering can and should be recognized and become a major impetus to improve our legal system, Rego said.

Anna-Maria Rabia, Chief Executive of the Australian Academy of Science, echoed calls for an independent review commission in all the countrys jurisdictions.

Here in New South Wales, weve just seen the crushing of the convictions of Kathleen Folbigg after 20 years in jail. If a case of this magnitude does not trigger law reform, Im not sure what does, she said.

It is time for Australia to review its legal system to ensure it can be more scientifically informed, particularly given the pace of change of scientific discovery and technological advances. (CNN)

PHOTO:Kathleen Folbigg, right, is embraced by friend Tracy Chapman outside the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal in Sydney, Dec. 14, 2023. Dan Himbrechts/AAP Image/AP

Comments

Post Comment

Guns boom, teargas rains as Wike, Bala Mohammed, Makinde, others battle for control of PDP National Secretariat

Guns boom, teargas rains as Wike, Bala Mohammed, Makinde, others battle for control of PDP National Secretariat

TD Africa takes centre stage at Schneider Electric Innovation Day Nigeria 2025, signs landmark MoU for AI-powered data centres

TD Africa takes centre stage at Schneider Electric Innovation Day Nigeria 2025, signs landmark MoU for AI-powered data centres

Full chat between Gen. Uba and rescuers before his capture and execution by ISWAP terrorists

Full chat between Gen. Uba and rescuers before his capture and execution by ISWAP terrorists

Canada warns against travel to Nigeria, 16 other African countries in latest security update

Canada warns against travel to Nigeria, 16 other African countries in latest security update

US Religious Freedom Coalition hails Trump for designating Nigeria a Country of Particular Concern, urges swift action

US Religious Freedom Coalition hails Trump for designating Nigeria a Country of Particular Concern, urges swift action

Outrage as Nigerian immigrant stabbed to death at home in South Africa

Outrage as Nigerian immigrant stabbed to death at home in South Africa

Tension in Enugu community as Gov Mbah's kinsmen protest military invasion

Tension in Enugu community as Gov Mbah's kinsmen protest military invasion

Kebbi Abduction: How my daughter escaped after bandits killed my husband — Vice Principal’s Wife

Kebbi Abduction: How my daughter escaped after bandits killed my husband — Vice Principal’s Wife

Genocide: U.S. lawmaker alleges Tinubu lying, protecting own interest

Genocide: U.S. lawmaker alleges Tinubu lying, protecting own interest

Anambra Assembly worker dies over inability to repay loan as workers begin indefinite strike

Anambra Assembly worker dies over inability to repay loan as workers begin indefinite strike

VDM, comedian Mr Jollof risk jail over in-flight fight

VDM, comedian Mr Jollof risk jail over in-flight fight

Strike: FG’s ‘No Work, No Pay’ threat will escalate looming crisis — SSANU president

Strike: FG’s ‘No Work, No Pay’ threat will escalate looming crisis — SSANU president

Nigerian doctor sent to prison in UK for $268,000 fraud

Nigerian doctor sent to prison in UK for $268,000 fraud

Tinubu has less than 600 days to be flushed out — PDP chieftain

Tinubu has less than 600 days to be flushed out — PDP chieftain

Key facts about proposed UK asylum system reforms

Key facts about proposed UK asylum system reforms

Northern Governors condemn abduction of schoolgirls in Kebbi

Northern Governors condemn abduction of schoolgirls in Kebbi

Mbah okays 2025 promotion exercise for Enugu civil servants

Mbah okays 2025 promotion exercise for Enugu civil servants

Military action key to ending banditry in Zamfara — Northern elders

Military action key to ending banditry in Zamfara — Northern elders

I am proud of Super Eagles, Osimhen declares

I am proud of Super Eagles, Osimhen declares

UK to tighten refugee status, expand forced family removals under new plans

UK to tighten refugee status, expand forced family removals under new plans

Tuesday, November 18, 2025 2:48 PM
ADVERTISEMENT

Follow us on

GOCOP Accredited Member

GOCOP Accredited member
logo

NEWS EXPRESS is Nigeria’s leading online newspaper. Published by Africa’s international award-winning journalist, Mr. Isaac Umunna, NEWS EXPRESS is Nigeria’s first truly professional online daily newspaper. It is published from Lagos, Nigeria’s economic and media hub, and has a provision for occasional special print editions. Thanks to our vast network of sources and dedicated team of professional journalists and contributors spread across Nigeria and overseas, NEWS EXPRESS has become synonymous with newsbreaks and exclusive stories from around the world.

Contact

Adetoun Close, Off College Road, Ogba, Ikeja, Lagos State.
+234(0)8098020976, 07013416146, 08066020976
info@newsexpressngr.com

Find us on

Facebook
Twitter

Copyright NewsExpress Nigeria 2025