Fidelity bank banner UBA banner
Melaye’s recall is now constitution barred, By O. G. Chukkol

By News Express on 15/10/2017

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon Share on Google+

Views: 1,407

•O. G. Chukkol
•O. G. Chukkol

It has been in the news that Senator Dino Melaye has been evading the service of Recall Notice. All attempts by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to serve him have been abortive. It could be recalled that on June 23, 2017, his constituents submitted a petition to the INEC demanding his recall from the Senate. Amidst this issue of service, there is also another fundamental issue on point of law, to wit, what could be the position of the law if Melaye, again, approaches the court challenging the recall process as invalid, being out of time?

Or the question can still be put as follows: If the Constitution stipulates a time frame within which something shall be done, can that time be extended by any authority or person?

This question was succinctly answered by Supreme Court in the case of Marwa v Nyako (2012) LPELR-SC.141/201 as follows:

“It is settled law that the time fixed by the Constitution for the doing of anything cannot be extended. It is immutable, fixed like the rock of Gibraltar. It cannot be extended, elongated, expanded, or stretched beyond what it states...”

Similar situation (time limit stipulated by the constitution within which something was to be done) was in issue in the case of PDP V CPC (2011) LPELR-SC.272/2011 (CON). It was in respect of the 2011 general election, which produced Dr Goodluck Jonathan as president. Congress for Progressive Change (CPC), the party that sponsored Muhammadu Buhari as its presidential candidate decided to challenge the election. Motion was filed for dismissal of the appeal. The Court of Appeal being an election tribunal in presidential election matters refused to grant the prayers, as a result of which appellants appealed to the Supreme Court on the 21st day of July, 2011 and July 25, 2011 respectively. When the appeals came up for hearing on October 27, 2011; O Okpeseyi, SAN, and many other counsel wondered whether the appeals were still valid before the court, having regards to when the decision appealed against was delivered. The court called on counsel for the parties to address it on the effects of section 285(7) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), which provides that an appeal in an election matter shall be heard and disposed of within 60 days from the date of the delivery of judgment. After listening to arguments of counsel for both parties, Onnoghen JSC, who read the lead judgment held thus:

“It is clear that by the use of the word ‘shall’ in section 285(7) of the 1999 Constitution, the framers of the constitution meant to make and did make the provision mandatory, as it admits of no discretion whatsoever. It means that the sixty (60) days allotted in Section 285(7) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) cannot be extended even for one second, as the decision of the appellate court must be rendered ‘within’ sixty (60) days of the delivery of the judgment on appeal.”

Sylvester Ngwuta JSC, in a concurring judgment held:

“Section 285(7) of the Constitution (as amended) is a statute of limitation, with regard to the hearing and disposal of appeal in election matters. Any action brought outside a statutorily limited period is time-barred.”

Now in respect of Recall, it is constitutionally stipulated to be done within 90 days. For the avoidance of doubt, Section 69 of the Constitution provides that:

“(1) A member of the Senate or of the House Representatives may be recalled as such a member if:

(a)…. (b) the petition is, thereafter, in a referendum conducted by the Independent National Electoral Commission Within Ninety Days Of The Date Of Receipt Of The Petition, approved by a simple majority of the votes of the persons registered to vote in that member's constituency.”

On the strength of the decision of the Supreme Court cited above, it is humbly submitted that Dino's recall is dead by effluxion of time, because the 90 days within which he was to be recalled expired on the 23rd of September, 2017. Even the court of law has no power to extend the time. Because, even in CPC's case above, it was not Buhari or CPC's fault that the hearing was delayed. The delay was as a result of the vacation that courts went on, but the plea by Gadzama, SAN, that the Constitution be given broader interpretation by excluding Saturdays and Sundays in computing the 60 days, fell on deaf ears. Ngwuta JSC, remarked as follows.

“Much as I agree, and sympathise with the appellants, that they are not in any way responsible for the delay in the matter, I am unable to subscribe to the view that S.285 (7) of the Constitution 1999 (as amended), which is intended to limit time should be interpreted to expand time. That will be contrary to the intendment of the sub-section.”

Odili JSC, added: “It is not the function of a court of law to sympathise with a party in the interpretation of a constitutional provision merely because, appellants acted timeously and due to no fault of theirs, there is an effluxion of time allotted for the hearing and final determination of the appeal. Going along with what Chief Gadzama is asking of this court is to enter into and possibly take over the functions of the legislature and, so, the only avenue in dealing with the appeals before us is to do what ought to be done within the context of this constitutional provision of section 285 and declare the appeals dead; and they have been dead for more than 40 days, and that is the reality on ground. Nothing can change that.

In the light of the foregoing, the only option left for Kogi electorate is to start the recall process all over again.

However, it is hereby recommended that section 69 of the Constitution be amended to exclude Saturdays, public holidays and days spent in judicial proceedings in computation of time.

O. G. Chukkol is a law student of Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Kaduna State. He can be reached via 08032470318 or oliverchukkol@gmail.com

Source News Express

Posted 15/10/2017 12:08:05 PM

 

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon Share on Google+


 

CLASSIFIED ADS

 

You may also like...
NEMA prepares stakeholders for special operations

Benue killings: I can’t sleep for more than...

RIGHTSView: REASONS WHY NIGERIA IS BROKE

40 vehicles recovered from ex-Perm Sec ‘don’t belong...

1,356 federal directors fail promotion exams

1,000 Enugu APC members return to PDP

U.S. to overtake Russia as top oil producer...

Tiger Woods arrested, booked into jail

Senate challenges Jega to prove his bribery allegation...

Suicide bomber kills 5 worshipers at Redeemed Church...

Abia workers celebrate 7 months of no salary...

Super Eagles star Alex Iwobi in trouble for...

 

Latest News Atiku/Obi Advocacy Group flays Buhari over ‘despotic and totalitarian’ statement 2019: Don’t vote for any APGA candidate, Uwazuruike tells BIM-MASSOB members Nigerians want proper agenda not propaganda, Atiku tells Buhari Fire destroys 77 shops in Kano market 2019: The irony of a Buhari’s second term as campaign begins, By Rev. Fr. Evaristus Bassey Hypocrisy of Western countries on MTN $8.1 billion fine, by Femi Falana Unidentified gunmen kill Gov. Bello’s aide in Okene Crisis trails INEC listing of Imo SDP guber Nigeria may become desert, NCF warns Kwara health workers begin 3-day warning strike Okowa receives Super Eagles at Asaba International Airport •NFF President lauds FIFA approval of Stephen Keshi Stadium for int’l matches Ooni fast-tracks revival of Yoruba culture

 

Most Read NUDE PHOTO OF OMOTOLA JALADE-EKEINDE surfaces online (421,894 views) Nigerian female sex addict opens up, says ‘I like it with both men and women’ (390,387 views) Shameless Genevieve Nnaji exposes breasts in public (323,369 views) Finally named: The full list of friends of Nigerian female sex addict who prowled Facebook (271,855 views) OLUMBA OLUMBA OBU (the one who called himself God) IS DEAD (244,432 views) Igbo scholar disgraces Femi Fani-Kayode •Demolishes claims on Igbo/Yoruba history with facts and figures (227,619 views) Breaking News: POPULAR REVEREND CONVERTS TO ISLAM in Kaduna (Nigeria) (209,296 views) OBJ’s son reported dead in Lagos plane crash •Names of more victims emerge (190,857 views) My wasted years in Olumba Olumba Obu’s Evil Brotherhood (176,106 views) THE FINAL DISGRACE: Igbo scholar unleashes more facts about Igbo/Yoruba history, finishes off Femi Fani-Kayode with second article (168,706 views) Lagos plane crash: Journalist releases victims’ names (165,268 views) Gunmen kill ASP, 2 other police officers in vain bid to kidnap Rivers PDP chieftain (152,136 views)

 

Zenith Zero Balance First Bank chat banking

 

Categories Advertorials (3) African Press Organisation (81) Art & Literature (74) Business & Economy (3,798) Business Verdict (54) Columnists (964) Complaints & Requests (94) Enterprise & Opportunities (208) Entertainment (567) Features (669) Global Business Monitor (310) International (2,694) Interview (167) Live Commentary (28) Love Matters (146) Maggie's Blog (38) News (40,637) Opinion (1,144) Pidgin (13) Politics (7,777) Religion (901) Sports (1,780) Stock Watch (35) AMA & Al Jazeera Global Update

 

 

 

 

APO Group Partner

 

 

CLASSIFIED ADS

GOCOP Accredited Member

GOCOP Accredited member

 

 

Africa Media Agency and Al Jazeera